Skip to content

cmd/go: minimization during fuzzing can print several redundant lines #48709

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom
Closed
katiehockman opened this issue Sep 30, 2021 · 2 comments
Closed

cmd/go: minimization during fuzzing can print several redundant lines #48709

katiehockman opened this issue Sep 30, 2021 · 2 comments
Labels
FrozenDueToAge fuzz Issues related to native fuzzing support NeedsFix The path to resolution is known, but the work has not been done. release-blocker
Milestone
Go1.18

Comments

@katiehockman
Copy link
Contributor

I fuzzed the target provided in #48320 with -v, and the command line output looks pretty messy. It seems to be logging every single time the minimizer was able to create a crash with a smaller value, which ended up being ~200 times. Let's reduce this to only the most recent crash, if possible.

/cc @golang/fuzzing

=== FUZZ  FuzzFuzzer
warning: starting with empty corpus
fuzz: elapsed: 0s, execs: 0 (0/sec), interesting: 0
fuzz: minimizing 1232-byte crash input...
fuzz: elapsed: 0s, execs: 420 (8127/sec), interesting: 7
--- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.05s)
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
        --- FAIL: FuzzFuzzer (0.00s)
            dsa_test.go:19: minimize this!
    
    Crash written to testdata/fuzz/FuzzFuzzer/d8398164056fc45958535f08a1b29a7fd10a21f12c95b34d4b891c6f9842b6d3
    To re-run:
    go test crypto/dsa -run=FuzzFuzzer/d8398164056fc45958535f08a1b29a7fd10a21f12c95b34d4b891c6f9842b6d3
FAIL
exit status 1
FAIL    crypto/dsa      0.668s
@katiehockman katiehockman added NeedsFix The path to resolution is known, but the work has not been done. release-blocker fuzz Issues related to native fuzzing support labels Sep 30, 2021
@katiehockman katiehockman added this to the Go1.18 milestone Sep 30, 2021
@gopherbot
Copy link
Contributor

Change https://golang.org/cl/353355 mentions this issue: testing: write output to buffer when fuzzing

@katiehockman katiehockman self-assigned this Oct 6, 2021
This was referenced Oct 12, 2021
Closed
Open
@gopherbot
Copy link
Contributor

Change https://golang.org/cl/355909 mentions this issue: testing: write output to buffer when fuzzing

@golang golang locked and limited conversation to collaborators Jun 23, 2023
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
FrozenDueToAge fuzz Issues related to native fuzzing support NeedsFix The path to resolution is known, but the work has not been done. release-blocker
Projects
Go Security
Status: No status
Milestone
Go1.18
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@gopherbot @katiehockman